{"hindsight":true,"version":"1.0","label":"Hindsight analysis: what fixed alternative exit rules would have done to the trades that actually closed. Not a forecast, not advice; paper trading only.","window":{"start":"2026-11-15","end":"2026-11-21","tz":"Asia/Shanghai"},"rules":[{"id":"stop10","kind":"tighter stop-loss","text":"Sell the moment a position is down 10%"},{"id":"trail10","kind":"trailing stop","text":"Sell when it falls 10% below its best mark"},{"id":"lock","kind":"break-even lock","text":"Once up 10%, sell if it falls back to cost"},{"id":"take20","kind":"earlier take-profit","text":"Sell everything at +20%"}],"method":"Each closed trade is replayed on its own mark path (one mark per desk tick: what selling everything then would have returned after all costs). A rule that would have sold before the real exit uses that tick’s mark; otherwise the real exit counts. Book under a rule = the ledger’s book now − its real results on the trades closed in this window + the rule’s results on them. Trades closed before the engine recorded paths use a frozen backfill (ledger equity − cash from the chain, or the pool’s own on-chain price where a ledger held two positions).","ledgers":{"A":{"id":"A","name":"Rally","control":false,"bookEth":0.907454,"closedInWindow":0,"realizedEth":0,"withPath":0,"rules":{"stop10":{"bookEth":0.907454,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0},"trail10":{"bookEth":0.907454,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0},"lock":{"bookEth":0.907454,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0},"take20":{"bookEth":0.907454,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0}},"trades":[]},"B":{"id":"B","name":"Spark","control":false,"bookEth":1.143925,"closedInWindow":0,"realizedEth":0,"withPath":0,"rules":{"stop10":{"bookEth":1.143925,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0},"trail10":{"bookEth":1.143925,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0},"lock":{"bookEth":1.143925,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0},"take20":{"bookEth":1.143925,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0}},"trades":[]},"C":{"id":"C","name":"Dipper","control":false,"bookEth":1.005861,"closedInWindow":0,"realizedEth":0,"withPath":0,"rules":{"stop10":{"bookEth":1.005861,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0},"trail10":{"bookEth":1.005861,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0},"lock":{"bookEth":1.005861,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0},"take20":{"bookEth":1.005861,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0}},"trades":[]},"S2V":{"id":"S2V","name":"Tide","control":false,"bookEth":0.666376,"closedInWindow":1,"realizedEth":0.000346,"withPath":1,"rules":{"stop10":{"bookEth":0.661436,"deltaEth":-0.00494,"changed":1},"trail10":{"bookEth":0.661436,"deltaEth":-0.00494,"changed":1},"lock":{"bookEth":0.66446,"deltaEth":-0.001916,"changed":1},"take20":{"bookEth":0.676087,"deltaEth":0.009711,"changed":1}},"trades":[{"id":"S2V-10-26407875","commit":"754d8a11e5eb4bbf8f60a3d85a58d490429cd4d838d5669afe20548fd8156f49","symbol":"POPO","exitTs":"2026-11-16T18:41:08.630Z","pnlEth":0.000346,"pnlPct":0.86,"reason":"time_stop","src":"engine","marks":327,"best":1.5068,"worst":0.3904,"rules":{"stop10":{"ratio":0.8853,"pnlEth":-0.004594,"deltaEth":-0.00494,"firedAtMin":5},"trail10":{"ratio":0.8853,"pnlEth":-0.004594,"deltaEth":-0.00494,"firedAtMin":5},"lock":{"ratio":0.9608,"pnlEth":-0.00157,"deltaEth":-0.001916,"firedAtMin":170},"take20":{"ratio":1.2511,"pnlEth":0.010057,"deltaEth":0.009711,"firedAtMin":69}},"proof":"https://si.cloudsi.fun/d/754d8a11e5eb"}]},"S2M":{"id":"S2M","name":"Anchor","control":false,"bookEth":1.218253,"closedInWindow":1,"realizedEth":-0.012567,"withPath":1,"rules":{"stop10":{"bookEth":1.218253,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0},"trail10":{"bookEth":1.218253,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0},"lock":{"bookEth":1.218253,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0},"take20":{"bookEth":1.218253,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0}},"trades":[{"id":"S2M-40-26414307","commit":"becda9e5ebaf677103c48507976f2ca728512f8543defa324e4a8ee4758107c3","symbol":"POPO","exitTs":"2026-11-14T16:51:12.532Z","pnlEth":-0.012567,"pnlPct":-16.97,"reason":"stop_loss","src":"engine","marks":3,"best":0.9196,"worst":0.8303,"rules":{"stop10":{"ratio":0.8303,"pnlEth":-0.012567,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null},"trail10":{"ratio":0.8303,"pnlEth":-0.012567,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null},"lock":{"ratio":0.8303,"pnlEth":-0.012567,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null},"take20":{"ratio":0.8303,"pnlEth":-0.012567,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null}},"proof":"https://si.cloudsi.fun/d/becda9e5ebaf"}]},"R":{"id":"R","name":"Dice","control":true,"bookEth":1.579062,"closedInWindow":6,"realizedEth":-0.09285,"withPath":6,"rules":{"stop10":{"bookEth":1.608485,"deltaEth":0.029423,"changed":4},"trail10":{"bookEth":1.609871,"deltaEth":0.030809,"changed":4},"lock":{"bookEth":1.579062,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0},"take20":{"bookEth":1.579062,"deltaEth":0,"changed":0}},"trades":[{"id":"R-89-26459000","commit":"a7f749aed0f580cacec631df419b5c30260b57fa57e4b01ed211a72f33162fd6","symbol":"DCTY","exitTs":"2026-11-21T02:15:15.321Z","pnlEth":-0.016685,"pnlPct":-20.86,"reason":"stop_loss","src":"engine","marks":20,"best":1.0471,"worst":0.7914,"rules":{"stop10":{"ratio":0.8886,"pnlEth":-0.008911,"deltaEth":0.007774,"firedAtMin":15},"trail10":{"ratio":0.8886,"pnlEth":-0.008911,"deltaEth":0.007774,"firedAtMin":15},"lock":{"ratio":0.7914,"pnlEth":-0.016685,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null},"take20":{"ratio":0.7914,"pnlEth":-0.016685,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null}},"proof":"https://si.cloudsi.fun/d/a7f749aed0f5"},{"id":"R-88-26455824","commit":"b95c6e31f5484775f4911d9610c5f2cf31c69ae28930085970978c1d5bbee907","symbol":"POPO","exitTs":"2026-11-20T11:46:17.459Z","pnlEth":-0.012173,"pnlPct":-15.12,"reason":"stop_loss","src":"engine","marks":3,"best":1.0366,"worst":0.8488,"rules":{"stop10":{"ratio":0.8488,"pnlEth":-0.012173,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null},"trail10":{"ratio":0.8488,"pnlEth":-0.012173,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null},"lock":{"ratio":0.8488,"pnlEth":-0.012173,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null},"take20":{"ratio":0.8488,"pnlEth":-0.012173,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null}},"proof":"https://si.cloudsi.fun/d/b95c6e31f548"},{"id":"R-87-26445529","commit":"74c7811542d0fe37d29d03a909b6cb17e12335da6a1fee75faf93ef680e5ea93","symbol":"POPO","exitTs":"2026-11-19T02:41:10.985Z","pnlEth":-0.014875,"pnlPct":-18.31,"reason":"stop_loss","src":"engine","marks":9,"best":0.9734,"worst":0.8169,"rules":{"stop10":{"ratio":0.8874,"pnlEth":-0.009148,"deltaEth":0.005727,"firedAtMin":30},"trail10":{"ratio":0.8874,"pnlEth":-0.009148,"deltaEth":0.005727,"firedAtMin":30},"lock":{"ratio":0.8169,"pnlEth":-0.014875,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null},"take20":{"ratio":0.8169,"pnlEth":-0.014875,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null}},"proof":"https://si.cloudsi.fun/d/74c7811542d0"},{"id":"R-86-26437519","commit":"905da4c33a59524e6487650ab2bd4ff6f50ed4c6906cb82964219a91d29bdf55","symbol":"POPO","exitTs":"2026-11-18T00:11:09.859Z","pnlEth":-0.014977,"pnlPct":-18.26,"reason":"stop_loss","src":"engine","marks":10,"best":1.0112,"worst":0.8174,"rules":{"stop10":{"ratio":0.8914,"pnlEth":-0.008905,"deltaEth":0.006072,"firedAtMin":105},"trail10":{"ratio":0.9083,"pnlEth":-0.007519,"deltaEth":0.007458,"firedAtMin":75},"lock":{"ratio":0.8173999999999999,"pnlEth":-0.014977,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null},"take20":{"ratio":0.8173999999999999,"pnlEth":-0.014977,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null}},"proof":"https://si.cloudsi.fun/d/905da4c33a59"},{"id":"R-85-26429745","commit":"2f3d9f12c761988fd3d4acf67fab99c3bc16041052f327a74a93dde3467eb8ed","symbol":"POPO","exitTs":"2026-11-16T21:26:10.178Z","pnlEth":-0.014873,"pnlPct":-17.98,"reason":"stop_loss","src":"engine","marks":7,"best":1.0079,"worst":0.8202,"rules":{"stop10":{"ratio":0.8201999999999999,"pnlEth":-0.014873,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null},"trail10":{"ratio":0.8201999999999999,"pnlEth":-0.014873,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null},"lock":{"ratio":0.8201999999999999,"pnlEth":-0.014873,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null},"take20":{"ratio":0.8201999999999999,"pnlEth":-0.014873,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null}},"proof":"https://si.cloudsi.fun/d/2f3d9f12c761"},{"id":"R-84-26422087","commit":"3006fe7f0ff701bfddf85849f4d912782f6dfc6e40d241c9be85d8e436973ada","symbol":"POPO","exitTs":"2026-11-15T19:26:12.078Z","pnlEth":-0.019267,"pnlPct":-23.02,"reason":"stop_loss","src":"engine","marks":7,"best":1.0715,"worst":0.7517,"rules":{"stop10":{"ratio":0.8875,"pnlEth":-0.009417,"deltaEth":0.00985,"firedAtMin":9},"trail10":{"ratio":0.8875,"pnlEth":-0.009417,"deltaEth":0.00985,"firedAtMin":9},"lock":{"ratio":0.7698,"pnlEth":-0.019267,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null},"take20":{"ratio":0.7698,"pnlEth":-0.019267,"deltaEth":0,"firedAtMin":null}},"proof":"https://si.cloudsi.fun/d/3006fe7f0ff7"}]}},"biggestLeak":{"ledger":"R","name":"Dice","control":true,"rule":"trail10","deltaEth":0.030809,"bookEth":1.579062,"cfBookEth":1.609871,"trades":4},"biggestLeakChildren":{"ledger":"S2V","name":"Tide","control":false,"rule":"take20","deltaEth":0.009711,"bookEth":0.666376,"cfBookEth":0.676087,"trades":1},"sentence":"Biggest leak: Dice (the random control) would hold 1.6099 ETH instead of 1.5791 with a 10% trailing stop (+0.0308 ETH, 4 trades).","sentenceChildren":"Biggest leak among the children: Tide would hold 0.6761 ETH instead of 0.6664 with selling everything at +20% (+0.0097 ETH, 1 trade)."}